| Year |
Men's Champion |
Most Outstanding
Male Athlete |
Women's Champion |
Most Outstanding
Female Athlete |
| 2026 |
St. Thomas Aquinas (6x) |
Darwin Almonte Pena, STAC |
Dist. Columbia (4x) |
Kyndra Hines, UDC |
| 2025 |
Roberts Wesleyan (6x) |
Thomas McConnelee, RWU & Vincent Ohenhen, CSI |
Dist. Columbia |
Jadyn Mullen, RWU |
| 2024 |
Roberts Wesleyan |
Emmanuel Mena-Jimenez, STAC |
Dist. Columbia |
Jenna Capolupo, DYU |
| 2023 |
Roberts Wesleyan |
Jayden Bennermo, STAC |
Roberts Wesleyan (8x) |
Dayna Thompson, UDC |
| 2022 |
St. Thomas Aquinas |
Emmanuel Mena-Jimenez, STAC |
Roberts Wesleyan |
Iyanna Jackson, UDC |
| 2021 |
Roberts Wesleyan |
Sullivan Keller, DAE |
Roberts Wesleyan |
Meaghan O’Callaghan, MOL & Hailee Lowe, RWU |
| 2020 |
Canceled due to COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2019 |
St. Thomas Aquinas |
St. Jacob Diodonet, STAC |
Roberts Wesleyan |
Shannell Hibbert, UDC |
| 2018 |
St. Thomas Aquinas |
Stefan Adams, LIU Post |
Roberts Wesleyan |
Kristina Button, RWU |
| 2017 |
St. Thomas Aquinas |
n/a |
Roberts Wesleyan |
n/a |
| 2016 |
Roberts Wesleyan |
n/a |
Roberts Wesleyan |
n/a |
| 2015 |
Roberts Wesleyan |
n/a |
Roberts Wesleyan |
n/a |
| 2014 |
Queens (2x) |
n/a |
Dist. Columbia |
n/a |
| 2013 |
Queens & St. Thomas Aquinas |
n/a |
Georgian Court (1x) |
n/a |
| 2004 |
C.W. Post (1x) |
n/a |
C.W. Post (1x) |
n/a |
| 2003 |
NYIT (1x) |
n/a |
NYIT (1x) |
n/a |
| * The conference did not sponsor a championship from 2005-2012 |
|